Buyer beware: Don't get ripped off by fake reviews on Amazon

Astroturf isn't just for football stadiums anymore.

Credit: Reviewed.com / TJ Donegan
Our editors review and recommend products to help you buy the stuff you need. If you make a purchase by clicking one of our links, we may earn a small share of the revenue. Our picks and opinions are independent from any business incentives.

Shopping online is easier than ever, but making sure you get a good product you can trust is tough when you usually have to put your money down before you try it. And with online shopping becoming a $1 Trillion-With-A-T business, the scammers are out in full force. That means many products on sites like Amazon have to contend with an old problem: Astroturf.

What is Astroturf? It's when a company puts up fake comments or reviews of a product on sites to boost its profile and reputation. These fake reviews turn a 3-star product into a 5-star product and convince you to part with your money. Our friends at The Wirecutter took a look at this last year, but there are new trends in the world of fake reviews that can go unnoticed. Here's what you need to know to protect yourself in 2017.

Signs user reviews on Amazon might be fake

  • The company is a brand you've never heard of with no online presence
  • Reviews come from "easy graders" who only leave 5-star reviews
  • All the user photos of the product look the same and aren't meaningful
  • All the reviews use the same or similar-sounding language
  • All the best reviews are from the same time period
  • Almost no 1-star or 2-star reviews
  • The user names are just odd and don't feel right

Amazon has tried to highlight real reviews with its "Verified Purchaser" system, emphasizing reviews from accounts that actually bought the product in question. But even this isn't a perfect system, and when abused it means you're more likely to see fake reviews. Even if you stick primarily to top-selling products on Amazon you can get taken for a ride.

Take, for instance, this top-selling Bluetooth speaker we found while researching another story. It has a nearly perfect 5-star rating from over 30 reviews (nearly all of them marked "Verified Purchaser"), the manufacturer product photos look legit, it's a top-selling product in its category. Seems great, right?

Fakespot Speaker Analysis
Credit: Fakespot
Even Fakespot, which is supposed to suss out fakes, fell for this product's reviews.

To dig into this product a little more, you can turn to two sites that scan Amazon pages and look for signs of Astroturfing: ReviewMeta and Fakespot.

Even these sites yielded mixed results, though. ReviewMeta gives the Infinite X Outdoor Sports speaker a "Warn," citing "unnatural reviews." FakeSpot, on the other hand, gives the Bliiq speaker an A, saying it has over 90% quality reviews. In this case, the wording and names of the reviewers didn't raise a red flag, but the distribution of the reviews certainly should have.

ReviewMeta
Credit: ReviewMeta
ReviewMeta's algorithm flags this product as unnatural, and it adjusts the score down slightly as a result.

Both of these sites use algorithms to look for common signs of illicit review behavior. The problem? This behavior changes all the time, and scammers can easily switch up their tactics to get by them.

In this case, though, you have to trust your judgement. For starters, the brand name is off. It's Bliiq, but in the title it says it used to be "Orange Bolt." That's just weird. Also the reviews come from people like ROBERT Green, HARRY REX, Sullivan Jeff, and use similar-sounding language that don't dig into the product itself. There are also 97% 5-star reviews, when even the best products almost always have a few duds that earn them 1- or 2-star grades from people.

A little light Google work reveals a work-in-progress site for the Orange Bolt Infinite X, which is the same as the speaker being sold on Amazon. The site is basically empty, except for some characters that translate simply to "Click here to edit." Add those up and it's pretty likely you're looking at at least some fake reviews. It's impossible to know for sure, of course, which is why sussing out fake reviews is such a tricky business.

If you get tricked into buying a bad speaker you may not be able to get your money back. Tweet It

One nasty side-effect of this is these products are often only sold through third-party marketplace sellers. Even if they're fulfilled by Amazon, these sellers often have their own return policies separate from Amazon, so if you get a bad speaker you may not be able to get your money back.

As always, keep your head and use your best judgement when shopping online. Buying shady products is like a box of chocolates: you never know what you're going to get.

Our editors review and recommend products to help you buy the stuff you need. If you make a purchase by clicking one of our links, we may earn a small share of the revenue. Our picks and opinions are independent from any business incentives.

What's Your Take?

All Comments
Our editors review and recommend products to help you buy the stuff you need. If you make a purchase by clicking one of our links, we may earn a small share of the revenue. Our picks and opinions are independent from any business incentives.
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below